Lender Use of AI Could Bring Dealer Headaches

Nearly all U.S. auto dealers surveyed on lender payment terms said they see compliance risk for themselves in the difference between first quotes they present to consumers and final lender contract terms.
The findings come as dealers face increased regulatory scrutiny on the prices they advertise and then charge to customers.
The Federal Trade Commission has cracked down on multiple automotive groups this year over what it considers deceptive pricing, and California recently adopted a CARS Rule-style law governing the hot-button aspect of car-buying.
ELend Solutions and 700Credit polled 150 auto dealers, lenders and “allied industry professionals” in October, and 93% of auto dealers alone said the observed quote-to-terms misalignment could spell trouble for them with the FTC.
According to the companies, no matter which party brings about the disparities, auto dealers are the ones who are legally responsible.
The problem appears to lie in fewer lenders furnishing dealers with rate bulletin sheets, according to 92% of all survey respondents. And most respondents said that change has resulted from lenders’ use of “black box” artificial intelligence in decision-making, along with credit tier pricing.
The quote-to-terms issue can cause dealers to underquote to consumers by an average of $2,240 over the life of a loan, the companies said.
“These results are a wake-up call for our industry,” said eLEND founder and CEO Pete MacInnis. “Even if this ticking FTC time bomb does not go off – which is a big if – this chronic mismatch between lender terms and dealer quotes is a risk to customer satisfaction and profit per vehicle sold.”
Most dealer survey respondents said initial payment quotes change after lender approval in at least 75% of cases, creating conditions for deal rewrites and even dead deals, the companies said.
Lacking the rate bulletins, dealers are left without crucial data to calculate accurate initial payment quotes, according to the survey report.
“These findings confirm that lenders’ move towards proprietary AI machine-learning loan pricing models, and away from standard rate sheets, is forcing dealers to rely on guesswork that results in them chronically changing their payment quotes after lender approval,” MacInnis said.
Despite AI’s apparent role in the cited problem, most dealer respondents said it could also be part of the solution by predicting fundable contract terms early in the sales process.